The way I understand the rules you can have 5 holes for gripping purposes regardless of how many you use. ( just so long as they could be used by one hand) in addition you can have one hole for balance purposes. So just because he doesn't use the thumbhole does not prevent him from having a hole used to bring the ball into legal tolerance. Maybe someone with more knowledge of the rules will correct me but that's the way it looks to me.
Bookmarks